Recently a patient wanted to start some counseling. His matter: he was trying to figure out ‘what happened?” for something that occurred to him 30 years ago. He has dwelled on this for decades with other therapists. He struck me as a fellow who will never find the answer, and even if he did, it would accomplish nothing. I recommended he take a different approach, one based on letting go of the past and focusing on the present. It was time for him to give up the need to solve the mystery. This approach went over like a lead balloon; he hinted he did not think me a ‘proper psychiatrist’ for taking such an approach. After all, isn’t therapy all about going back to the past and working on it? Well, no, it is not. Sometimes ‘going back into your past’ can be a waste or time or even detrimental to your Journey to healing.
As I grow in experience I find I am getting more ‘practical’. I like to recommend treatments that “actually help”. These maneuovers are often antithesis to what was taught to me as dogma. Going back to the time when you were six years old and didn’t get enough brownies isn’t useful therapy for most neurotics.
“What works?” you ask. Here’s my quick list of 5 rules for mental health and well being. Mind! There are always cases of people who need to work on past events either as the treatment or as a prelude for the matters below. What I am trying to avoid is patients getting ‘stuck’ in the past. It truly sucks to be pushed into the pig pen. It is unjust and unfair, and people need a time for rage/anger and bereavement. And then they need to rise up and get out of the muck and move on.
Give up the need to know why something happened.
Like in my patient example, people get ‘hung up’ on ‘why did this happen to me?” If a few appointments can’t come up with a good enough answer, then it is sensible to stop trying to solve the mystery. “It happened”, perhaps for many reasons beyond our comprehension . I use the simile of an avalanche in your backyard. You have a backyard full of rocks that slid down from the mountain. Rather than trying to figure out which stone caused the avalanche, it is better to focus on how to go about cleaning it up.
Give up the need for control.
It is a sad paradox: the patients I see who are feeling ‘not in control’ are the ones most obsessed about control. I first explore with them what is so horrible or terrible about not being in control, and then work backwards from “the worse case scenario’ to an approach less black and white. Being somewhat in control rather than in control of everything is a more sane and healthier way of living.
Give up the past.
All great religions and philosophies promote living in the present; sensible advice indeed. I coach my patients to recognize when they are thinking/being in the past. They identify it, take a few breaths, call their spirit back from the past, and
go onwards. The positive attributes of the past are integral into the present: the negative attributes are better left behind.
Give up negativism.
This one may sound funny, but how we approach things makes a difference. When someone asks you how you are doing, think a moment. Before you respond “Oh, terrible, my issues are making me miserable (or words of that effect)” say something like ‘Overall OK, despite some things I am holding my own, I am doing well enough’. This is not hypocrisy or suppression; this is helping you to remember your blessings and avoid the pitfall of gloom.
Give up living your life to fulfill the expectations of others.
Squelching your Self for the approval of others causes illness. Prostituting your Self for security, approval, or even profit is no prettier. We all have to do some to survive; hopefully not enough we get lost in it.


21 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 16, 2012 at 2:13 PM
anne marie in philly
the 5 things you describe here were told to me by my therapist 10 years ago; and she was ABSOLUTELY correct!
I don’t give a shit what anyone else thinks of me; I live life for me and me alone.
April 18, 2012 at 5:18 PM
ronzorro
I’m with you on this Anne Marie!
April 16, 2012 at 2:22 PM
wfregosi
“All great religions and philosophies promote living in the present”
Philosophies, perhaps; but religions? Aren’t we living in a reactionary era in which the three major religions are to one degree or another insisting on a return to the fundamentals of their scriptures? The place of women in modern society is under assault from these religions with the object of turning back the clock and subjecting them to male control.
April 16, 2012 at 2:31 PM
Urspo
What Fundies are doing and the true message of most religions are vastly different to the Founder’s words. Where I was going with this is in Buddhism and Christianity (at least) are the concepts “Be not afraid: be in the present, and don’t worry about the future” but trust The Divine that things are how they should be. Live neither in the past nor the future.
April 16, 2012 at 3:33 PM
Will J
A friend caught be off guard yesterday. She pointed out that I had started something by saying yes to a new possibility. Although the events did not transpire according to plan, I started with yes and that made it all OK. I would not have realized this otherwise.
April 16, 2012 at 4:22 PM
Old Lurker
Was the dogma to use therapies that didn’t “actually help”?
I find your notes from the office fascinating, although I worry that soon I will be sent the bill.
April 16, 2012 at 6:08 PM
Brent
I really enjoyed this blog entry. Besides me taking this advice, I know a few others who should as well.
April 16, 2012 at 8:07 PM
Rick
Ugh, I love wallowing in the past. Eventually we give up all control. Until then, I am not riding in a car with someone else driving. Well not if I don’t have to. Hmmmm, I think I kind of enjoy being negative at times.
Another good post. I know you’re right. Thanks
April 16, 2012 at 11:02 PM
Nik_TheGreek
Really nice post!
You are right. However, sometimes it is easier said than done. You need a clarity to always remember these rules that doesn’t always come in time of need. Maybe it needs practice…
April 17, 2012 at 5:16 AM
Urspo
A life time of practice.
________________________________
April 17, 2012 at 1:35 AM
tim
I was wondering too, how much do I owe?
Thanks
April 17, 2012 at 5:52 AM
Shawn
Fabulous!
You are Fabulous!
April 17, 2012 at 7:50 AM
Raybob
Interesting: the shamanic healing practice of Soul Retrieval as (re)pioneered by Sandra Ingerman (herself a licensed counselor) has one way of addressing this “stuckness” thing. Soul Retrieval is an indigenous soul-medicine practice predicated on the belief in many world societies that when we experience something traumatic or even very, very exciting, a portion of our vital essence can leave us, often taking with it some memory of the event. Sandra’s contention as a therapist and as a shamanic practitioner of several decades’ duration is that you can’t effectively deal with a problem in therapy if the portion of yourself that experienced it is not here with you to do the dealing-with.
In my brief, four years’ experience of both giving and receiving soul retrieval, this healing modality often fills in the gaps and allows a person to move forward and get out of being stuck in that place of non-understanding; you might not have an entire understanding of what happened, but most often you have the resources to move out of the stuck place afterward.
April 17, 2012 at 7:56 AM
Urspo
The one the most amazing cases I know about is a Navaho man who was in extremely bad shape; his elders put him down a well and told him to call back his Spirit. In the process he encountered and forgave the most abominable hurts and realized some of them were not the way he thought of them. This half hour down the well did more than the decades of Medicine.
April 17, 2012 at 10:13 AM
Mitchell Block
Great advice and fascinating comments too.
April 18, 2012 at 8:37 AM
Tony Davis
i like your list, and i think i will use your avalanche metaphor with my own clients! i also feel that it is better to decide what to do now rather that dwell on what was done in the past. however, i don’t like the wording of “let go of the past”, and maybe that is why so many people find this difficult to do. there is a difference, to me, between letting go of the past and not being affected by the past. the latter can be done without forgetting what your life has been, and what has been overcome. i would not want to relive the painful times in my past, but i would not want to let them go either, because i really like who i am today, which is partly a result of all that mess! maybe a re-wording would help your clients with the process of focusing on their present choices? ha. listen to me. the intern advising the doctor. the nerve.
April 18, 2012 at 5:20 PM
ronzorro
I understand what you’re saying Tony. I agree with you that our past not only is who we are today but part of our lives today. The more we understand our past the more we understand and accept who we are today. However, we do not want to repeat the mistakes of our past but learn from them. Sometimes this takes a lifetime as I am finding out now.
April 20, 2012 at 9:03 AM
Tony Davis
Personally, Ron, I do not like to look at anything in my past as a “mistake”. It was an experience that either caused joy or pain, in a nutshell. I did the best I could, and all I need to do now is decide if I want to repeat that experience. If it was painful, the answer is usually obvious. Same thinking as you, just different framing.
April 22, 2012 at 3:18 AM
ronzorro
Tony,
I agree with you absolutely. I also do not look at any of my past experiences as a “mistake” but rather as a learning experience. I’m still “learning.”
Ron
April 18, 2012 at 5:23 PM
ronzorro
Dr. Spo,
I think I’ve pretty well figured out from my past experience the person I am today with all my fears, weaknesses, hope and strengths. However, the main thing is that I am a survivor as are many who make the effort to understand how their past experiences have affected their life and the way they are today. One thing I know for sure, if I could go back in the past (say when I was 20 years old) knowing what I know now, oh how much different my life would be today. Wishful thinking for sure.
April 18, 2012 at 5:41 PM
Doug
First, I must apologize for being away for so long. I do, in fact, read all your entries, but they are usually in batches of two or more weeks at a time.
I must say you are one of the wisest therapists I know of. And this entry is excellent proof of that. Many therapists, or those I have seen anyway, focus solely on the past and spend inordinate amounts of time sorting through minutiae from my childhood. I think you hit the nail on the head when you say you try to find treatments that “actually help.” What an excellent idea! Love this post.