The day after Thanksgiving is marked for making soup. Truth be told I enjoy making and eating turkey soup more than the actually turkey dinner of yesterday. The turkey dinner can be hit or miss but turkey soup is forgiving.* I used to follow recipes for this, but I’ve learned over the years this doesn’t require any it is make-it-up-as-you-go-along using whatever is at hand. I follow the ancient recipe:
- Take whatever you have
- Boil it in water for a while
- Eat it.
First step is to get out the carcass from last night and strip it of as much meat as possible for Someone to make a pot pie. There is usually enough left on the bones of the bird for the soup. The late Ann Marie AKA Warrior-Queen (may she rest in peace) gave me a few years ago an electric knife after I mentioned wanting one here for some years. I think of her whenever I use it.
Harper who can sleep through earthquake is awake and by my side for this step, begging for turkey bits, which she gets, but she is insatiable. She doesn’t mind those nasty bits covered in ‘jelly’ which I dislike.
The only question (still unanswered which is better) is to sauté the vegetables first adding the turkey or add them chopped to the simmering soup. This year I am doing the latter, using up some not-so-crunchy carrots and limp-looking celery in the fridge. I am having sense to let the carcass simmer for as long while to let water take on as much flavor as possible before adding herbs and salt and such.
The simmering soup gives the house a nice smell. After an hour or more I pick through the soup and remove all the bones, which are bereft of meat. Some folks strain all of this and just use the broth and add fresh new vegetables and chopped meat but I figure they are there already so what the hell. My way saves on vegetable but there is always a surprise bone bit in the servings.
Near the end there is the question whether or not to add a starch like pasta or egg noodles. There is a half box in the pantry of small orzo-like pasta whose only use is in soup. If I add chopped potatoes Someone is less likely to eat it. Egg noodles are my favorite but these lovelies could be used later on in a tuna fish casserole so I guess I will use the pasta bits after all.
One year I added a fancy rice but we both thought it overpowered the soup. This is turkey soup dammit not rice soup.
No matter how I make turkey soup it comes out more or less OK and there is enough to feed a well-patronized soup kitchen. Some if it will be eaten this weekend but a lot will be put into containers and frozen for later. I must must must remember to label these things as all frozen container contents look alike.
So that’s what I am doing this day. Someone is working at the convention hall in which a nation-wide bridge tournament is being held. My eyes cross at the sorts he must have to contend with today. I am glad to be at home in the kitchen stirring once, stirring twice, stirring turkey soup no rice.
*Yesterday’s turkey was a flop. We followed the advice of J. Kenji López-Alt on how to cook a turkey. He has never steered me wrong so I suppose the failure lies in operation error. The white meat was OK but the legs and inner thigh region came out hardly looked. Oh the horror. Someone and I took off some of the breast meat and ate with relish washing it down with large amounts of Gewurtztraminer wine to kill any bacteria. I put the bird back in the oven and we forgot about it engrossed in Doctor Who. The now well-done bird was a bit beyond table presentation but what the hell it’s going in soup and pot pies anyway. I may write Mr. Lopez-Alt to tell him his recipe is a turkey.
16 comments
November 25, 2022 at 12:28 PM
David Godfrey
My Someone recoils at the odd bit of bone, or cartilage, so if I make stock, I MUST strain it. Onions I think should be sauteed before being simmered in liquid, celery goes either way, I read something recently on mushrooms that said it really does not matter how they care cooked, unless you are frying them and want them crispy. I tossed the carcass, I just didn’t feel like the work. I was at Wegmans today and did buy a bone in turkey breast (a handicap turkey – no wings or legs) that I will roast off soon. There is never enough left over turkey.
November 25, 2022 at 12:32 PM
Brian Dean Powers
Our dinner yesterday was delicious; with all the trimmings. However, there was far too much salt in some parts. Which left me thirsty all evening. Not that I’m complaining.
November 25, 2022 at 1:09 PM
Debbie W.
Your turkey soup sounds delicious, and I’m a vegetarian! I love the image of Harper by your side, waiting for turkey bits. ❤️
November 25, 2022 at 1:16 PM
DwightW.
“Waste not , want not” I like your style!
November 25, 2022 at 1:22 PM
Old Lurker
I am glad Harper got some turkey bits. She is such a good dog that she deserves a small plateful of leftovers. You can make up some excuse if Someone inquires why there is less for his pot pies.
November 25, 2022 at 1:29 PM
Lori Hawkins
Enjoy your soup. I’m making Brunswick stew with some of our leftover turkey on Sunday. There is SO much leftover meat.
Binx had a bit of turkey yesterday for the first time and really enjoyed it. I’m glad Harper did too.
November 25, 2022 at 3:25 PM
Anonymous
Spatch-cocked — faster to cook, all parts done at the same time, moist meat and crispy skin. You will never go back to another recipe. I did this with 15 lb turkey at 450 degrees f, it was done in one hour and fifty min.
November 25, 2022 at 3:36 PM
Will Jay
Tip from Captain Obvious : cook the pasta separately and add it at serving time so it doesn’t go all mushy and unappealing in the batches sent to freezerland. I like your aproach of that it is soup, so how would it know ( i.e. don’t tell the soup pot what is gouing on). I’m a fan of sauteing the sacrificial aromatics on the theory that it builds up a small amount of fond that helps the soup along on its way, or “… because I think the soup likes it.”
November 25, 2022 at 4:10 PM
Linda Practical Parsimony
I like your recipe for soup. I just put vegetables in soup and do not saute vegetables. Actually, I would boil the carcass, strain and use broth for soup. But, it is your soup. I don’t make turkey soup. I probably should some day.
Harper knows that sound comes with meat. Funny! Smart girl.
November 25, 2022 at 4:32 PM
BadNoteB
Isn’t it amazing that Harper and kin instinctively recognize the intense flavors of collagen and other proteins in bone that we had to discover through prolonged steeping – like bone tea – to extract and enjoy in the diluted form of stock? That has always fascinated me and continues to prompt wonder what we might be missing by not burying them in the backyard for a few weeks (or months?) prior to use… Either way, I’m glad she got to enjoy her turkey tidbits and “jelly”.
If it’s any consolation for the latest fancy recommended cooking method not working to your satisfaction, chefs have been seeking “the perfect” roasting approach for these oversized culinary atrocities for centuries with little apparent luck or progress. Momma Nature stacked the deck against us in a structural/physiological sense with the turkey. To date, the only perfectly cooked turkey I’ve encountered has been in large production kitchens where white and dark structures are severed, then roasted separately. This approach destroys the classic Dickens whole-bird presentation we tend to romanticize, however, making it unacceptable to most for home use.
May your ‘22 Turkey Soup turn out perfectly. Hopefully there’s some left-over Gewurtztraminer and a fresh batch of homemade bread to accompany!
November 25, 2022 at 6:39 PM
Ron
Yum! Soup! And you’re doing it the right way with the Turkey carcass cooking in water. Soup is very forgiving. I recently discovered a fabulous cabbage beef soup recipe. My MAGA neighbor Bob M., who often gives me his chicken soup ( little in the bland side but well intentioned), I gave some of my cabbage soup. He’s addicted to it now as I am. Not only is cabbage soup good for the body it’s good for the soul, so comforting. Also makes for good neighbors.
November 25, 2022 at 6:39 PM
Dark Raider Robzilla
I baked a Marie Callendar’s frozen turkey dinner last night. I’m doing it again right now. Too bad neither has enough meat to make a proper sandwich like I suggested the other day.
Hopefully the soup turned out fine. There’s always next year, right?
November 25, 2022 at 7:56 PM
Sluggy
When doing the whole bird and you want every part(light and dark)to cook to the same temp/doneness try spatchcocking your bird. You’re welcomed.
Enjoy your soup too.
November 26, 2022 at 5:16 AM
Hugh W. Roberts
I’m sorry the turkey was not all to your liking but good to see you are using the remains in a soup. Here in the UK, we have turkey at Christmas, and the remains are often made into a curry and eaten before the New Year. Some also use the remains for making turkey sandwiches.
November 26, 2022 at 5:57 AM
Elle
We are vegan so no turkey leftovers but hope you have enough left over to eat during that football game today! (A house full of vegans & Buckeyes! The horrors!) Should be a good game. Take care & holiday wishes from Ohio!
November 26, 2022 at 12:44 PM
Urspo
I am writing this on a Saturday. I had forgotten ‘that game’ was today until several friends (who all went to that school in Ohio, now how did this happen?) reminded me by sending mean-spirited (albeit funny) memes about my alma mater. Oh the pain. One has promised someday to show me that campus as I have never been there. What a bucket list!
I thank you for your salutations from Ohio!